Car and Driver hosts hybrid hoedown, hearts Ford Fusion heaps

Filed under: Hybrid, Chevrolet, Ford, Nissan, Toyota, USA

With 4 of the worlds top brands now boasting mid-size sedan hybrids in their line ups, the chaps over at Car and Driver decided it was time to rustle them all together and see how they stack up. If you’ve been torn over whether to buy a hybrid in the shape of a Toyota Camry, Ford Fusion, Nissan Altima or Chevy Malibu, this is the comparo that can save you days of visiting dealerships and conducting your own set of test drives. To save you even more time, we break down their observations into a handful of bit-sized chunks, from worst to first.

The Chevrolet Malibu hybrid was the “mild hybrid” of the bunch. While its appearance has been praised by some, its engineering earned few accolades from the C&D crew. They found the start/stop system rudely abrupt and the electric assist seemed to surge off and on with a mind of its own while under way. It not only came last in mileage (19.8 mpg city! Dude!), it also came last in acceleration. The can of tire inflation product in lieu of an actual spare only adds insult to injury. Let’s hope GM puts more effort into the Volt. A lot more. Hit the jump to see how the others contestants fared.

Gallery: 2008 Chevrolet Malibu hybrid